Fav Antenna
Fav Antenna
I'm trying to find a new antenna for my mobile so I figured this would be a good way to choose. The choices are ones that I might go with but not sure yet.
-
Bozo Verified
- Site Admin
- Posts: 9,455
- Joined: August 31st, 2004, 1:06 pm
- Handle: Bozo The Clown
- Real Name: James
- Antenna: Monkey Made MM9
- Radio: General Lee Radio
- Contact:
-
jessejamesdallas Verified
- Wordwide & Qualified
- Posts: 6,287
- Joined: October 10th, 2004, 7:02 pm
- Handle: Jesse James Dallas
- Real Name: Jesse
- Radio: working
- Contact:
-
Bozo Verified
- Site Admin
- Posts: 9,455
- Joined: August 31st, 2004, 1:06 pm
- Handle: Bozo The Clown
- Real Name: James
- Antenna: Monkey Made MM9
- Radio: General Lee Radio
- Contact:
-
Bozo Verified
- Site Admin
- Posts: 9,455
- Joined: August 31st, 2004, 1:06 pm
- Handle: Bozo The Clown
- Real Name: James
- Antenna: Monkey Made MM9
- Radio: General Lee Radio
- Contact:
How did I miss this poll?
Well, "Other" isn't listed...so I didn't vote. Everyone talks highly of the 10k, but I've yet to see anyone compare it (even unscientifically) to the 102" whip...which I know for a fact the Everhardt Tiger SOTT-5' will out perform. I've run numberous tests over the years using the 102" as the base antenna to beat.
Well, "Other" isn't listed...so I didn't vote. Everyone talks highly of the 10k, but I've yet to see anyone compare it (even unscientifically) to the 102" whip...which I know for a fact the Everhardt Tiger SOTT-5' will out perform. I've run numberous tests over the years using the 102" as the base antenna to beat.
-
jessejamesdallas Verified
- Wordwide & Qualified
- Posts: 6,287
- Joined: October 10th, 2004, 7:02 pm
- Handle: Jesse James Dallas
- Real Name: Jesse
- Radio: working
- Contact:
I have tested the 10K against the 102" whip. Was posted on another site...231 wrote:How did I miss this poll?
Well, "Other" isn't listed...so I didn't vote. Everyone talks highly of the 10k, but I've yet to see anyone compare it (even unscientifically) to the 102" whip...which I know for a fact the Everhardt Tiger SOTT-5' will out perform. I've run numberous tests over the years using the 102" as the base antenna to beat.
I also did the test useing the Wilson 5000, the Mr.Coily Dual Coil 22" shaft antenna, the Monkey Made, the Megatron, (which is a Monkey Made Clone) And a Radio Shack antenna...
In every case...The Predator 10K always was the most broad banded antenna, and tuned the lowest, and easiest...All test were done using a Dosy Meter, and a radio shack meter, a field strength meter, and a mfj 259b antenna analyzer...
All antennas were similar in size's, number of coils, and shaft lengths. (except for the 102" whip, Predator doesn't make anything close to 102" tall)
Over all best preforming antenna was the Predator 10K, 27" shaft Dual Coil antenna. Tuned flat across all 40 channels, on mfj. 100% Match efficiency, X=0 on all 40 channels...
Also tested were the other Predator 10K configurations, like the Single Coil, the 22", 17", 12", and 9" shaft's...All did well, but the 27" tuned the best.
As for the antenna which came in a close second, other than Predator. Was the Mr.Coily.
Best I could get the 102" whip to tune, was around 1.2 swr. Which from what I've seen, most cant get a 102" to tune lower than 1.3...
102" whips are just fine if your sitting still. But run down the highway @ 60 MPH, and watch that sucker bend-over backwards! Along with the swr!
The Heavy **Censored** Made's wont bend at all, not even @ 150 MPH down the freeway...But they also wont talk as good either.
But, you don't have to take my word for it...talk to anyone who use to run whips, but finally decided to switch to the 10K!
By the way...I do alot of the testing of the Predators, before they ever go to market...The antennas which are for sale right now, are some of the best antennas available. Currently, I have a couple of different Predator's I'm testing, and different size diameter's of shafts...And still playing around with a "Top-Hat" or Ground Plane kit, made by Predator, for Predator 10K's...
Only way to find out if the Predator 10K is for you...is to give one a try!
Do not argue with an idiot. He will drag you down to his level and beat you with experience.
Well, why not? The 102" whip mounted on your car will exibit 0, ZERO dBd gain.... because it's a half-wave dipole [the other half is the car] With coils comes loss. That's just a rule of thumb. So what's this about a SCOTT antenna?231 wrote:How did I miss this poll?
Well, "Other" isn't listed...so I didn't vote. Everyone talks highly of the 10k, but I've yet to see anyone compare it (even unscientifically) to the 102" whip...which I know for a fact the Everhardt Tiger SOTT-5' will out perform. I've run numberous tests over the years using the 102" as the base antenna to beat.
My choice isn't listed so hear is my favorite (I am SO ready for the crap from all you....heehee). I messed up my little wil that I used to run so I went to a truck stop and bought this Cobra 1000 mag mount. It has this big coil cased in glass and filled with oil. So far, it is the best antenna I have run hands down on my van. But, it is only like my second antenna I have tried. My little wil had to be totally adjusted before I could even come close to 1.5 on my SWR. This Cobra went straight to 1.3 across the board without modification upon hook-up.
Just my 2 cents.
Just my 2 cents.